Reading your interesting and thoughtful comments, my strongest thought and reaction is to both wrap you up in a giant, warm and snugly cuddle, to treasure and reassure you, while also slapping your critics round the head with a baseball bat, to try and beat some common sense and empathy into them! Perhaps an unusually strong reaction, but there we go!
So many thoughts here...
Firstly "family" and closeness. If you cannot share closeness, your secrets and your childhood discoveries and exploration with your siblings then I do feel that something has gone wrong. Children discover things that stir and interest their sexual selves while growing up... this should not be a surprise or a shock to anyone.
But this is a vast world away from sexualising children, appealing to or appeasing paedophiles, or asking for the reader to lust after or desire a child! *shudder*
I accept this has to be done carefully and sensibly, but for me, claiming that sexual nature and being springs fully formed into being on the day someone becomes a legal adult is both stupid, and also demeaning to the character, and it ignores so much of what goes to form us and make us who and what we are.
Seeing and knowing where a person finds and considers the roots of their sexuality can add greatly to understanding them, empathising with them, and being drawn into their world and their pleasure, which is what good erotic writing is all about, as far as I am concerned.
I wanted to touch on this in my first comments since to me it is an important point, but only one of many. Here you have siblings engaging in something that is clearly a sexual act, but recognising that is a WORLD apart from sharing and partaking in a sexual act together! I feel that you have shown, captured and explored this point very well here, and I like how it adds both "spice" and emotional depth to the story and the characters.
I am sorry to hear about the death of your friend, this is going to hurt, and leave a hole in your heart. But loss is part of life. It doesn't make it any less, but ignoring it, pretending it doesn't happen seems stupid to me. Surely it is better to celebrate the good and the happiness they brought with them, to mark their life and their achievements?
Yes, bondage can be dangerous, so can breathing, walking, or getting out of bed. Life cannot be lived risk free, but risk should be considered and managed.
Personally I tend to dislike stories that totally ignore the physical realities of bondage, but this comes from a desire to see how the problems are tackled. Stories are fantasies, not reality. Seeing a "not perfectly practical" but erotic and fun solution to what the body needs is much more satisfying to me than ignoring the problem all together, since it helps me to picture and "inhabit" the situation, to put myself into the characters place, the better to visualise and enjoy the emotions and experiences the story seeks to provoke.
Not everything is for everyone, that's fine! I don't enjoy everything I read, but that doesn't make the story bad or wrong, just not something I want to read.
Another comment that really stands out for me is about women being far more severe than a man. I want to nit pick this, but that's just me being bloody minded, and in general I very much agree. Personally I like male / female energy in bondage stories and interaction, but more than this, I want to see the bondage become "real", it has to actually take away something, otherwise it isn't bondage, its just dressing up. So to achieve this pushing limits is almost required by definition, and here family seems perfectly placed to make this happen in a safe yet deeply evil way *happy evil smirk*
Personally I would love to see more of this story, of these characters, as you explore some more of what makes this such a fun and erotic experience [
]